Healthcare is best delivered by a team of professionals working together for the good of the patient. Each member is trained for a specific role, with specific training requirements commensurate with responsibility. Independent practice of Physician Assistants and Nurse Practitioners not only fractures the team with dissension, but it blurs the role of each team member, and results in substandard patient care.
Jeremy Sunseri, MD
Emerald Coast Medical Association
Florida Patient Protection Coalition formed to combat misinformation regarding the level of education, training between physicians and mid-level practitioners
(Tallahassee, Fla.) – More than 50 County Medical and Specialty
Societies across the state today announced the formation of the Florida Patient Protection Coalition (FPPC) to educate the public on the
benefits of physician-led, team-based care and to combat the false and
vitriolic narrative spun by supporters of House Bill 607 related to health care practitioners.
“The Florida Patient Protection Coalition seeks to counter the propaganda being disseminated by the nursing and physician assistant groups pushing for independent practice legislation,” said FMA President Ronald F. Giffler, MD, JD, MBA. “The Florida Medical Association believes that independent practice and team-based care take healthcare delivery in two very different directions. Independent practice further compartmentalizes and fragments health care delivery, while team-based care fosters greater integration and coordination.”
There are vast differences in the education
and training of physicians compared to that of non-physician health care
practitioners. A Medical Doctor must complete four years of medical school
followed by three or more years of graduate medical education, which includes
at least 15,000 clinical training hours (see graphic below).
In contrast, advanced nursing degree programs
only recommend 500 post-baccalaureate hours (about 12 weeks) of clinical
training for Masters of Science in Nursing degrees and 1,000 post-baccalaureate
hours of clinical training for Doctorate of Nursing Practice degrees. Advanced
Practice Registered Nurses (APRNs) are not required to complete any training
beyond graduate school, whereas Medical Doctors complete three to seven years
of residency training in a select surgical or medical specialty under
experienced physician faculty supervision.
“As a member of the Florida Patient Protection
Coalition, it is critical we push back on special interest groups who seek to
compromise the quality of health care by allowing Advanced Practice Registered
Nurses and Physician Assistants to practice beyond the scope of their education
and training,” said Christie Alexander, MD, President, Florida Chapter of the
American Academy of Family Physicians.“This coalition believes
patients’ best interests are optimally served when they are treated in a
physician-led, team-based model of care.”
- According to a 2013 study by the Mayo Clinic, inappropriate referrals to tertiary referral centers by APRNs and Physician Assistants (PAs) could offset any potential savings from the increased use of APRNs and PAs.
- A JAMA Internal Medicine study found that APRNs and PAs were associated with more ordered diagnostic imaging than primary care physicians.
- A brief report by the Infectious Diseases Society of America found that ambulatory visits involving APRNs and PAs more frequently resulted in an antibiotic prescription compared with physician visits.
- Physician supervision is the norm, not the exception:
- States that do not allow APRNs to practice independently make up roughly 70% of the population.
- 9 of the 10 most populous states do not allow APRNs to practice independently.
Across the country, patients overwhelmingly
want a coordinated approach to health care, with a physician leading the health
care team. Key findings from AMA 2012 and 2018 surveys include:
- Ninety-one percent (91%) of respondents said that a physician’s years of education and training are vital to optimal patient care, especially in the event of a complication or medical emergency.
- Eighty-six percent (86%) of respondents said that patients with one or more chronic conditions benefit when a physician leads the primary health care team.
- Eighty-four percent (84%) of respondents said that they prefer a physician to have primary responsibility for the diagnosis and management of their health care.
About the Florida Patient Protection Coalition (FPPC)
Joined by more than 50 state medical professional societies, the FMA has launched the Florida Patient Protection Coalition to educate the public about a dangerous legislative proposal, HB 607, which would allow Advanced Practice Registered Nurses (APRNs) and Physician Assistants (PAs) to practice independently without any supervision from licensed physicians. The coalition’s new website, www.floridapatient.com, also explains the importance of physician-led, team-based care while highlighting the vast difference in physicians’ education and training compared to that of nurse practitioners and PAs. This collaborative effort shows that Florida’s medical community is unified in protecting patients, and it also counters the propaganda from special interest groups that are urging state lawmakers to pass independent practice legislation.
Listing of Florida Patient Protection Coalition members
- Alachua County Medical Society
- Bones Society of Florida
- Brevard County Medical Society
- Broward County Medical Association
- Capital Medical Society
- Charlotte County Medical Society, Inc.
- Clay County Medical Society
- Collier County Medical Society
- Dade County Medical Association
- Duval County Medical Society
- Emerald Coast Medical Association
- Escambia/Santa Rosa County Medical Society
- Female Indian Physicians of South Florida
- Florida Academy of Family Physicians
- Florida Academy of Pain Medicine
- Florida Chapter – American Academy of Pediatrics, Inc.
- Florida Chapter American College of Physicians
- Florida Chapter American College of Surgeon
- Florida Chapter Division of the American Academy of Emergency Medicine
- Florida Chapter, American College of Cardiology
- Florida College of Emergency Physicians
- Florida Medical Association
- Florida Orthopedic Society
- Florida Osteopathic Medical Association
- Florida Psychiatric Society
- Florida Pulmonary Society
- Florida Radiological Society
- Florida Society of Anesthesiologists
- Florida Society of Dermatology and Dermatologic Surgery
- Florida Society of Nephrology
- Florida Society of Neurology
- Florida Society of Ophthalmology
- Florida Society of Pathologists
- Florida Society of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
- Florida Society of Rheumatology
- Florida Society of Thoracic & Cardiovascular Surgeons
- Florida Urological Society
- Florida Vascular Society
- Hillsborough County Medical Association, Inc.
- Indian Physicians of South Florida
- Lake-Sumter Medical Society
- Lee County Medical Society
- Manatee County Medical Society
- Marion County Medical Society
- Palm Beach Medical Society
- Physician Society of Central Florida
- Pinellas County Medical Association
- Polk County Medical Society
- Sarasota County Medical Society